I Found Something Wrong on My Credit Report. What Should I Do?

Stage 1 of the Credit Report Error Guide

You checked your credit report and something looks wrong.

Maybe there is an account you do not recognize. Maybe it says you missed a payment when you know you paid on time. Maybe the balance is wrong. Or maybe something shows up on Experian but not on Equifax or Trans Union.

Do not panic. And do not assume it is correct just because it is on your credit report.

Credit reports can have mistakes. Your first job is to figure out exactly what looks wrong.

Here are some of the most common problems to look for.

1. Information That Is Not Yours

Why is someone else’s information on my credit report?

Sometimes information from another person can end up in your credit file. This is often called a mixed file. It can happen when two people have similar names or other similar information.

Look for things like:

  • Names you do not recognize
  • Addresses where you have never lived
  • Phone numbers that are not yours
  • Accounts you have never opened

If something is not yours, write down exactly what is wrong. Do not just say, “My credit report is wrong.” Say, “I have never lived at this address,” or “I never opened this account.” That will matter later.

Why is there an address or name I do not recognize?

An unfamiliar address does not automatically mean someone stole your identity. It could be old information, a mistake, or information connected to an account you had years ago.

Ask yourself:

  • Have I ever lived there?
  • Have I ever received mail there?
  • Could this be connected to an old account?
  • Is the name just another version of my name?

If none of those make sense, make a note of it.

Can my credit report get mixed up with someone with a similar name?

Yes. Information from one person’s file can sometimes end up connected to another person’s file. This matters most when an account, collection, or late payment that belongs to someone else shows up on your report.

If you see something like that, document it.

2. Accounts You Do Not Recognize

Why is there an account on my credit report that is not mine?

First, do not assume fraud. Look closely at the account.

Check:

  • Company name
  • Account type
  • Date opened
  • Balance
  • Payment history
  • Account status

Sometimes a company appears on your credit report under a different name than the one you know. But if you check the account and you are sure you never opened it, used it, or cosigned for it, that is something you should investigate.

Does an account I do not recognize mean someone stole my identity?

Not always. There could be another explanation.

The important question is: Do I simply not recognize the company name, or is this truly an account I never opened?

If someone actually opened an account using your identity without permission, that may be identity theft.

What if a collection account is not mine?

Start by figuring out what debt the collection company is trying to collect. You may not recognize the collection company’s name even though you recognize the original debt.

If the underlying debt truly is not yours, write down exactly why. “I never opened this account” is much more useful than “I do not recognize this collection company.”

3. Wrong Late Payments or Account Status

Why does my credit report say I was late when I paid on time?

Check your records:

  • Bank statements
  • Payment confirmations
  • Account statements
  • Receipts
  • Emails from the company

Then compare them with your credit report.

Example:

Credit report says: 30 days late in May.

Your records show: The payments due in April and May were both made on or before their due dates.

A payment is generally reported as late only once it is at least 30 days past its due date, so a late mark in May may relate to a payment that was due in April. Compare your payment dates with the due dates, not just the month.

Now you have identified the exact problem.

Why does a closed account show as open?

First, make sure the account really was closed. Find a statement, email, letter, or other record showing when it was closed.

Then compare that with your credit report. If your report says the account is open but your records clearly show it was closed, you have found something specific to investigate.

Why is my payment history wrong?

Do not look at the whole account at once. Look month by month.

If your report says you were late in March but your bank statement shows you paid on time, save that record.

You want to be able to say, “My report says I was late in March. My statements show I paid the February and March bills on or before their due dates.”

Why does the report say I am responsible for an account when I was only an authorized user?

Look at how the account describes your role. There is a difference between being responsible for an account and simply being an authorized user.

Write down what the report says and what your actual role was.

4. Wrong Balances, Limits or Dates

Why is my balance wrong?

Credit reports are not always updated immediately. If you made a payment very recently, your report may not show it yet.

But if the balance continues to be wrong, compare your credit report with your account statements.

Example:

Credit report: $8,400 balance

Latest statement: $3,200 balance

Now you have something specific to investigate.

Why is my credit limit wrong?

Compare what is on your credit report with your actual statement.

Example:

Credit report: $5,000 limit

Account statement: $10,000 limit

Save the statement.

What if the dates are wrong?

Pay attention to when the account was opened, when you last made a payment, and when the account first became delinquent.

If a date looks wrong, check your old statements and records. Do not guess. Write down what the report says and what your records show.

5. Duplicate or Old Information

Why is the same debt showing twice?

First, make sure it really is the same debt. Two similar-looking accounts are not always duplicates.

Compare:

  • Account numbers
  • Original creditor
  • Balance
  • Dates
  • Collection company
  • Account status

If two entries appear to be connected to the same debt, write down both of them before taking action.

Why is an old debt still on my credit report?

Negative information does not disappear immediately. Many types of negative information can generally stay on your credit report for about seven years, although the rules depend on the type of information.

Do not assume something is wrong simply because it is old. Check what happened, when it happened, and what dates are being reported now.

Why did something that disappeared come back?

If you previously disputed something, it disappeared, and now it is back, save everything.

Keep:

  • The old credit report
  • Your dispute
  • The response you received
  • The report showing it was removed
  • The new report showing it again

Do not delete those documents. They may become important later.

6. My Credit Reports Do Not Match

Why does Experian show something that Equifax or Trans Union does not?

Your three credit reports do not always match. That does not automatically mean one of them is wrong.

A company may report information differently or may not report to all three major credit bureaus.

Do not ask, “Which credit bureau is right?” Ask, “Which report matches what actually happened?” Check your real account records.

Why are my three credit reports different?

Some differences are normal. But differences can also help you spot mistakes.

Compare the same account across all three reports:

  • Balance
  • Payment history
  • Account status
  • Credit limit
  • Important dates
  • Who owns the account

Then compare those details with your actual records.

How Do I Know If Something Is Actually Wrong?

Ask one simple question:

What specific fact on my credit report do I believe is wrong?

There is a big difference between “This late payment is hurting my credit” and “They are reporting me late in June, but I paid on time and I have the bank statement.”

There is also a difference between “I want this collection removed” and “This collection is not mine.”

Something hurting your credit does not automatically mean it is inaccurate. The main question is whether what is being reported is true.

What Should I Do First?

Do not start sending random letters. Exercise caution in using a credit repair company to “clean” your credit. Many are not reputable. You can dispute errors yourself. And do not dispute everything negative just because it is negative.

Start by getting organized.

  1. What does my credit report say? Write down exactly what is being reported.
  2. What do I believe is actually true? Be specific.
  3. What is wrong with what they are reporting? Explain the difference in one sentence.
  4. What proof do I have? Look for statements, receipts, emails, payment records, letters, or other documents.
  5. Which credit reports show the problem? Check Experian, Equifax, and Trans Union.

Then save everything.

Here Is What You Are Trying to Figure Out

You want to go from:

“Something is wrong with my credit.”

to something specific like:

“Experian says I was 30 days late in May. I paid on time, and I have my bank statement showing the payment.”

Or:

“This collection is on my Trans Union report. I have never had this account, and I do not recognize the original debt.”

That is Stage 1.

You are not trying to prove a lawsuit. You are not trying to become an expert on the Fair Credit Reporting Act.

You are simply answering:

What is being reported, and what do I believe is wrong about it?

Once you can answer that, you are ready for Stage 2.

Stage 2: Is the Information Actually Inaccurate?

Finding something suspicious does not automatically mean your credit report is wrong.

Next, we will help you compare what is being reported with what actually happened.

You will learn:

  • What counts as inaccurate information
  • What does not
  • What proof can help
  • How to organize your evidence
  • How to get ready for a dispute if the information really is wrong

Next: What Counts as Inaccurate Information on a Credit Report?

The 5 Stages

Stage 1 — Find the Problem
Something does not look right.

Stage 2 — Confirm What Is Wrong
Figure out exactly what is inaccurate.

Stage 3 — Dispute It
Ask for the inaccurate information to be investigated and corrected.

Stage 4 — It Still Is Not Fixed
Figure out what to do when the problem remains after your dispute.

Stage 5 — Understand Your Options
Learn when it may make sense to speak with a consumer-law attorney.

Reviewed by Hashim Rahman, Esq.

ATTORNEY ADVERTISING. This information should not be construed as legal advice or legal opinion on any specific facts or circumstances. Contacting us does not create an attorney-client relationship. Rahman Legal is located at 43 West 43rd Street, Ste. 204, New York, NY 10036, and at 68 Jay Street, Ste. 201-N/15, Brooklyn, NY 11201, Tel. 212-970-9801.

Contact Us Today
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.